Jon, FWIW, I know there are hundreds of recipes for Apple Pie, and I have tried a lot of 'em.
However, I would like to offer the following for you to think about, since you seem well on your way to doing "a batch".
I would suggest looking for a couple of large, dark colored brown jugs, for putting your squeezins in....gallon jugs are great for this.
My wife and I make several batches of "home-made" Kahlua, Irish Cream, and Apple Pie, just about every single year, and we have been doing this for about 25 / 30 years.
Now that the "kids" are all grown, and have their own families, they all look forward to the Thanksgiving get together, because that's when they all get their Holiday liquor from Mama Bear's booze closet. She even put labels on it, and how it's made, and of course, what's in it.
We have always used dark jugs/bottles for making these kinds of drinks, as the dark color supposedly "mellows" the mix....we also store them in a dark place while they are working off, and nothing is touched for a minimum of 45 days, other than "tilting, or shaking gently"....no peeking, no checkin, no sneakin a little drink, or even letting direct light on the jug!!
I have tried Apple Pie from a lot of folks, some good, some not so good, and some downright wild!....still yet, it was interesting.
Most folks who have tried ours say it is one of the best they have ever tasted.
The number one prerequisite for Apple Pie is that it be easily drinkable...
One of the best "enhancers" we have found for Apple Pie is a Hot Cider Mix made by Lipton. It comes in a little bag, like tea, and you just pour hot water over it and drink it.
Mama Bear uses 10 bags of this, per quart of water....very strong!
Soooo, One quart of boiled Hot Cider Mix, one pint of concentrated frozen apple juice, one pint Everclear, and two cups of light brown sugar, aged in a brown glass container for 45 days.... very simple, but it will surprise you at how drinkable it can be.