Traditional Muzzleloading Association

Shooting Traditional Firearms and Weapons => General Interest => Topic started by: Ohio Joe on October 14, 2016, 10:06:11 PM

Title: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 14, 2016, 10:06:11 PM
I only have one L&R Flintlock, the Smaller John Bailes, and I like it. For those that have the following - how do you feel about the L&R Durs Egg Flintlock?

I'm working up a build for in the Spring (2017), and just want to go with something I haven't used yet (L&R Durs Egg)...

Your thoughts?
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: RobD on October 14, 2016, 10:15:20 PM
i had the L&R durs egg in a .54 fowler a few years back, thought it was good, found no fault with it.  

jackie's putting an L&R queen anne in the new .62 smoothie due in to me next month, hope it's just as good.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 14, 2016, 10:25:18 PM
Thanks Rob... :shake
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: RobD on October 15, 2016, 05:09:09 AM
hmmm, been awhile, but don't remember the L&R durs egg as being "main spring heavy".  if i recall correctly, it did work best for me with a 5/8 x 3/4 english flint.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 15, 2016, 07:38:35 AM
Thank you Rob, I appreciate the info. I'm pretty well convinced that I'll be ordering the L&R.  :lt th
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Two Steps on October 15, 2016, 12:45:54 PM
Joe...I have a L&R Durs Egg on a .50cal early TN rifle.  I've had it since 06 and haven't noticed any problems with it.  It's pretty fast (and I'm darn sure not a good "tuner") and the spring feels fine to me. as always YMMV.  Good luck!
Al
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 15, 2016, 06:07:24 PM
Quote from: "Two Steps"
Joe...I have a L&R Durs Egg on a .50cal early TN rifle.  I've had it since 06 and haven't noticed any problems with it.  It's pretty fast (and I'm darn sure not a good "tuner") and the spring feels fine to me. as always YMMV.  Good luck!
Al

Thanks Al, I appreciate the information. I've got that building itch, so the Durs Egg it is.  :lt th
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 09:07:54 AM
I have had some problems with that model in the past, but they are fast when you get them tuned up properly. The biggest problem is the cock goes too far into the pan and the blast coming out of the vent hole blows your flint edge off or rounds it off. To solve this You need to add some material to the cock where it rests on the lock plate when it is all the way down, it lifts the flint out of the way of the vent hole that way. Inspect your lock carefully when you get it, I used an L&R lock recently and quality control seems to be slipping a bit, crooked screws, tumbler wobble, frizzen fit is bad, etc. Also get a full set of spare internals as these locks are notorious for breaking parts until you get a good set in it.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/Borders%20double%20gun/borders10.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/Borders%20double%20gun/borders7.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/Borders%20double%20gun/borders3.jpg)
This is a double I built years ago that uses the Durrs Egg locks. You can see on the left one that the flint is now up and away from the vent hole now. These locks now are very good and very fast, this gun has won "Top Gun" on the sporting clays range at Friendship many times.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 09:12:58 AM
BTW, Have you used Chambers late Ketland yet? It is easily 2X the lock that the Durrs Egg is. Chambers quality is hard to beat and that particular lock is probably the fastest factory lock on the market.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/Borders%20squirrel%20rifle/br3.jpg)
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: RobD on October 16, 2016, 09:23:27 AM
chambers-siler late ketland is nothing less than Superb.  i've had them on my last two rifles, and one is going into the new flintlock "hawken" rifle.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 16, 2016, 10:10:53 AM
Quote from: "Mike Brooks"
BTW, Have you used Chambers late Ketland yet? It is easily 2X the lock that the Durrs Egg is. Chambers quality is hard to beat and that particular lock is probably the fastest factory lock on the market.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/Borders%20squirrel%20rifle/br3.jpg)

Mike, thanks for the heads up on the Durs Egg. I appreciate your input for sure. Almost sounds like the luck of the draw if you get one.

I will take a look at the Chambers lock, I know they are considered top notch just like the Siler locks. Glad you jumped in here. We all value your reputation as a builder. Thanks again!  :shake
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 16, 2016, 10:15:16 AM
Quote from: "Rob DiStefano"
chambers-siler late ketland is nothing less than Superb.  i've had them on my last two rifles, and one is going into the new flintlock "hawken" rifle.

I agree completely Rob.  :shake
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 16, 2016, 10:30:47 AM
Quote from: "Mike Brooks"
BTW, Have you used Chambers late Ketland yet? It is easily 2X the lock that the Durrs Egg is. Chambers quality is hard to beat and that particular lock is probably the fastest factory lock on the market.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/Borders%20squirrel%20rifle/br3.jpg)

Mike, is that the Classic Ketland?
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 11:11:16 AM
I'm not sure exactly what Jim calls it. When I order one I always ask for the Late Ketland. He also sells an "early Ketland" which would be good on a much earlier gun. In fact for early guns my favorite Chambers lock is the "early Ketland'.  I just built myself a deer hunting gun a month ago using the early Ketland. It's as fast as the "Late" and is super easy on flints. I have close to 50 rounds through it and am still using the same flint Jim sent with the lock, haven't even knapped it yet. Killed a coyote on the run with it late yesterday afternoon. Head shot believe it or not!. It's always better to be lucky than good!
 Here's the gun, 29" swamped Colerain barrel, early ketland lock, Iowa grown black walnut stock. This is a "stripped down" model I built just for my own hunting purposes, bare minimum of parts to get the job done.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/350%20English%20Gamekeepers%20Rifle/350a_zpsbuy0jkrj.jpg)
The rest of the pics are here if you want to see them.
350 English Gamekeepers Rifle by Gunmaker | Photobucket (http://smg.photobucket.com/user/Gunmaker/library/350%20English%20Gamekeepers%20Rifle?sort=3&page=1)
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 11:16:47 AM
Also, for more options on later guns I have used this lock by RE Davis with excellent results. I can't remember what they call it....
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/0703/Gunmaker/345%20NC%20Deep%20River%20repop/345b_zpswswhyedv.jpg)
Had a little trouble with it off the start, operator error. Once I flipped the flint over and used a bit longer flint it's now real fast and dependable, good flint life too.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Bigsmoke on October 16, 2016, 11:29:29 AM
Sure am sorry to hear of the decline if quality for the L & R locks.
We used them for several years on our big bore rifles and always had excellent results.
Frankly, I have been away from the gun building market since 2005 and have not really kept up much contact with that part of the muzzleloading world, having been most interested in powder horn building.
Well, so it goes, I reckon.
John
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 12:58:03 PM
Maybe I just got a bum lock, I don't very often use L&R locks so that could be the case. They do now use a forged mainspring instead of the cast ones they used to use. I understand that casting flaws from the casting factory made it near impossible to get a mainspring that wouldn't fail after some use. The forged main spring seems to work well, but I'm not sure it would change out to replace an old cast spring with out a little wood removal in your lock inlet. Maybe it would, you'd have to try it and see I guess, wouldn't take much to fit it.
 I had a fowling gun that I used their Queen Anne lock on. It was a champ of a lock, fast and dependable and I got 140 shots out of a flint once. Only problem was a broke frizzen spring that they replaced for free. Also, they replaced my worn frizzen for free at that time too. I kept the worn one on the gun and kept the new replacement in case the  worn one quit working. Probably had around 8,000 rounds out of that gun or more. Used it for skeet and sporting clays.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: RobD on October 16, 2016, 12:59:53 PM
the chris walker smooth rifle i just sold has a davis colonial american 2 screw lock, another goodie for sure.

(http://www.redaviscompany.com/images/products/1122big.jpg)
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 16, 2016, 01:12:00 PM
Food for thought for sure.  Glad to hear L&R switch their mainspring manufacturing.

BTW; nice coyote shot, Mike!  Luck, or not... :lt th
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: RobD on October 16, 2016, 01:13:29 PM
Quote from: "bigsmoke"
Sure am sorry to hear of the decline if quality for the L & R locks.   .... <snip!>

i find that very hard to believe and before ya know it, *some* folks reading this thread may unfairly forge a black mark on L&R locks.  

L&R, davis, chambers, and surely others - these reputable name brand folks will all stand by their products, they'd be complete fools not to since their market is a small niche sport and they're all in a competition of sorts.  i'd give 'em all a fair opportunity to back up their offerings and take care of their customer's product issues.
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 16, 2016, 01:59:49 PM
Quite right Rob!  :lt th
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 04:10:42 PM
Just trying to pass along my personal experience as a lot of locks go through my hands. As I mentioned, I could have just got a bum lock. When you get your lock take a good look at it, if it fits your needs I'd use it. I've had locks from the Rifle Shoppe that are cast from originals that were made with out interior bridles and the tumblers had the wobbles yet they're still going strong!

Back in the 80's all the competitive shooters liked the L&R locks because of their short hammer throws and generally smaller lock size which made them pretty fast. I thought they were great locks and they have always had great customer service if you have trouble. Now there is a lot of competition from other lock makers and that gives all of us an incredible amount of choices. All seems good to me. :rt th
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Mike Brooks on October 16, 2016, 04:22:52 PM
Quote from: "Rob DiStefano"
the chris walker smooth rifle i just sold has a davis colonial american 2 screw lock, another goodie for sure.

(http://www.redaviscompany.com/images/products/1122big.jpg)
That is a great lock too, I have probably used 1/2 dozen of them since they came out...probably more. It's really fast for a big lock and is dependable. I think the internals are the same as their Jeager lock.  I ordered one from TOTW last week for a jeager rifle I want to build for myself this winter. I just got the barrel from Bobby Hoyt, Swamped 25" .58 cal with a 1 in 34 twist. All of the original jeagers I have handled all have one twist in the length of the barrel I was too chicken to go with a 1 in 25 so Hoyt suggested a 1 in 34 instead. I'm trying to figure out what the old timers knew and we forgot.....fast twist with a big ball and short barrel....doesn't make much sense today, but I'm going to figure it out. I'm thinking lightish powder charge and a very tight patch/ball combo something like a 50 yard masher..... We'll see!
This will be the 3rd gun I have built for myself this past year. I got tired of never having a ML to shoot so I vowed to fix that problem....now I can't stop! :laffing
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Ohio Joe on October 16, 2016, 04:47:27 PM
Mike, I haven't built myself a new rifle in I don't know how long? I know the feeling, but I'm only going to do one more for myself... :shake
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: RobD on October 16, 2016, 04:58:55 PM
Quote from: "Ohio Joe"
..... I'll use the Bailes capper for a new build for my grandson when he's a bit older. Least ways that's the plan. :bl th up  :salute  

oh, wait,  :rofl   :shake
Title: Re: What's Your Thoughts On L&R Flintlocks?
Post by: Hawken on October 16, 2016, 11:46:36 PM
I don't have a problem with them!

(https://c7.staticflickr.com/9/8294/29163627182_2871c6d0f2_b.jpg) (http://https)FlPerc (http://https) by Sharps Man (http://https), on Flickr