Traditional Muzzleloading Association

Craftsmanship => Accoutrements => Topic started by: jbullard1 on September 11, 2008, 08:44:50 PM

Title: Dye Problem
Post by: jbullard1 on September 11, 2008, 08:44:50 PM
I am trying to dye my white cotton pants with boiled walnut hulls. I left them in the hot solution for a couple of hours then took them out. my wife wanted them washed so I did and now they are almost white again. Other than Rit any ideas??
Title:
Post by: david32cal on September 11, 2008, 09:09:01 PM
Jerry you may have to leave it in the solution for a couple days for it to set in, if you hav'nt already add a handful of salt to it and stir it two or three times a day.
Title:
Post by: Mitch on September 11, 2008, 09:20:26 PM
get yourself about 1 pound of salt, one gallon of vinegar and one gallon of water...mix well, put those pants in the "mordant" let it sit awhile....pull the pants out of the mordant, wring'em out good(back into the mordant bucket), then put the pants in the dyebath for about a week, wring'em out good(back into the dye pot) and DON'T wash'em with soap....hang the pants up and let'em dry...then put about 2cups of baking soda in the washer(NO SOAP!!) and run'em thru....should give'em a bit of color and you can repeat as needed...hope this helps, I've dyed A LOT of stuff this way and it works for me...
Title:
Post by: Uncle Russ on September 11, 2008, 09:34:25 PM
Jerry, a bit off subject, but in reference to Rit Dye....

I am the first to admit that I have a problem trying to dye anything, especially brown, the color with which I have had the most failures!

Now my wife, she who knows everything about everything worth knowing, has informed me that the dye we get today is not the same dye we were getting twenty plus years ago...apparently she read somewhere that the additives we have in our water today, which are all somehow for the betterment of our health ....has caused a need to change the original formula, or older formula, and if we use "pure rain water" we will see better results.

Now, what I'm thinking is that principal may somehow apply to walnut hulls....Don't know, just thinking out loud.

Uncle Russ...
Title:
Post by: jbullard1 on September 11, 2008, 09:52:56 PM
You may have a point Unc Russ
Title:
Post by: Gobbler on September 12, 2008, 12:41:43 AM
Just my experience but Mitch has hit the nail on the head for Walnut dye with salt and vinegar solution as well as the time
in the dye. I have dyed quite a bit and have left it in the dye pot for 2 weeks sometimes. I use green walnuts and slice the hull with a knife then boil the walnut for a while and let cool then add clothing. I also find that some of my best shades have been some of the worst looking and smelling dye pots. You just skim the mold and yuk off the top of the solution and throw stuff back in. I have a pot full since last fall that I still use. hope this helps. I suppose I should change it some day, but it's a little like Elk Camp Coffee you just keep adding more to it  :lol: Also not that it is perfect but my blanket shirt in my avatar started out a white wool hospital blanket (military surplus)
Title:
Post by: Captchee on September 12, 2008, 09:38:55 AM
my first question would be , are your pants 100% cotton ?.

 next would be did you use green walnut hulls  or dried ?
 green hulls will  dye  just about anything   even your hands but the color can be darker  from my experience.
 I would also agree with what gobbler and the others have said .
 We used to have an old porcelain  canning pot that my dad kept his  walnut die in for traps  .
 What he would do is add paraffin to the boiling water . Once it was all liquefied, we would dip our traps .
 This would  take off the  human sent and wax the trap all in one process.
 When this mix cooled , the paraffin would then cool on the top    of the liquid. Mom would then break it up and put it back in the shelf  tell the next time . She would then add another hand full of green walnuts  and just leave the pot sitting out side .
 The thing would  have in a few days , all kinds of stuff  in it ., bugs , mould , you name it. As I recall it smelled to high heaven  and got pretty thick . Something like real good coffee
 But in no time if you dipped anything in it , that item even metal would come out  almost black   .

 if you have some old iron laying around , it wont hirt to toss a peice of it in as well

 What you need to do is soak your pants   for a few days . Take them out and rinse them in cold water . If the color isn’t ark enough , soak them again . When you reach the depth of color you think want , go a little darker  because when they dry  the color can lighten up some ..
 Now what we do is miz up a cold water , vinegar and salt  mix  and rinse the item in it . This sets the dye . Pretty good .
 Now let the item drip dry . don’t wash it in a machine. Machines are designed to scrub cloths . You don’t want the item scrubbed, just let it  dry naturally..

 Later once dry  you need to wash the item a couple times with a genital product like woolite    . Do it by hand and the colors will last longer .
 The other thing to keep in mind is natural dyes often fade over time with regular washing
Title:
Post by: jbullard1 on September 12, 2008, 10:02:41 AM
I  used dry walnut hulls
Need to get out and round up a few green ones
Thanks for the help
Title:
Post by: Ridge on September 13, 2008, 09:34:34 AM
Natural dyeing is sort of a hobby of mine.

First, don't try to dye new clothing. The dye solution wants to run off of it. You should wear/wash the heck out of anything you plan to dye. It will take a better color.

Second...why all the cold dye baths? That may stain your clothing, but it won't dye them.

Just wash those britches about 10 or 12 times and then boil some walnut hulls in a cast iron pot. Let the solution cool some and then steep the pants for about an hour.

If you don't have a cast iron pot, just throw some old rusty pieces of metal into the solution as you are boiling it. All you are doing is adding a mordant.
Title:
Post by: Captchee on September 13, 2008, 10:28:55 AM
i believe its because  the theory  in it is that hot water opens up the  material to accept the dye  . cold water will not  and thus only rinses of the dye that’s on the surface  of the material .

 While I was in the service , I had a chance to tour Japan for a couple weeks .  A couple of the smaller villages at that time still dyed silks  in the old way . I remember the rivers below their villages would run the colors of the dye’s  for some ways . It was very interesting  and wonderful to see .

My wifes mother  told me that as a child she often helped  in dying  silks for kimonos  and such  .
 She lived with us  through her last years  and when I dyed my  Alasdulo, I ask her advice
My mother also dyed her Quills  much the same way . Hot water  for applying the color and cold for the rinse.
I dyed my Alasdulo with raspberries  doing the same process I  described . that’s how she showed me
 It came out a nice red  and the color has lasted  some 5 or 6 years  now .
Im sure there are other ways , but that’s just how I was shown to do it . it worked for me
Title:
Post by: Captchee on September 13, 2008, 10:52:55 AM
my wife gave me the name for  this . its called "Yuzen-nagashi "
so i looked it up

(http://shofu.pref.ishikawa.jp/shofu/intro_e/PICTURE/H_P50506.gif)
Yuzen-nagashi :to wash the paste
and excessive dye out with cold water
Title:
Post by: Gobbler on September 13, 2008, 11:00:58 AM
Ridge
I would agree with boiling also,  just didn't state it that way after I read my original post again the only thing I would caution is be careful with leather and new material as has been stated before. I found out how to make a set of leggings for a toddler out of my 12 year sons pair :shock: anyway I beleive you just have to work with it a little to perfect your own way.
Title:
Post by: Loyalist Dave on September 15, 2008, 08:00:35 AM
Quote
if you have some old iron laying around , it wont hirt to toss a peice of it in as well.
 Quite Right!

Folks please note "one mordant does not fit all".  A Mordant, an additive to help the dye take and to make it more colorfast, is often determined by the type of dye and the fabric which is died.  Now the salt will work a bit for some natural dyes ( and it works great on Rit Dye - a chemical dye), and the vinegar is good for wool to keep it color fast, but...,

Walnut hulls work best with iron oxide.  An iron kettle with the hulls boiled at least a day works well ;  letting the cloth sit for several days works even better.   IF you don't have an iron kettle, not to worry, take some 4-0 steel wool, and boil it (removes residual oils) and let it sit in a mason jar of water, or water and vinegar to rust.  When so rusty you really can't see through the water to the other side, boil your hulls and add the rust solution.  (You may want to strain out any leftover bits of metal as these may spot your fabric).  Should work well.

LD
Title:
Post by: Mitch on September 15, 2008, 01:57:40 PM
well, I guess the way I've been dyeing dang near everything(wool, linen, cotton,leather,etc) "theoretically" doesn't work according to some...and I've cold dyed EVERYTHING with walnut hulls or hickory,pecan hulls.....y'all can dye how you choose, but if you haven't tried the way I suggest, don't tell me it won't work....
Title:
Post by: Captchee on September 15, 2008, 03:08:55 PM
Quote from: "Mitch"
well, I guess the way I've been dyeing dang near everything(wool, linen, cotton,leather,etc) "theoretically" doesn't work according to some...and I've cold dyed EVERYTHING with walnut hulls or hickory,pecan hulls.....y'all can dye how you choose, but if you haven't tried the way I suggest, don't tell me it won't work....

 i dont think thats whats being said mitch . i think in fact  what is being said is that there are many ways  to make  things work  ;)
Title:
Post by: jbullard1 on September 15, 2008, 03:52:46 PM
Hey Mitch Thanks
I'm giving it a try we'll see how it works out in a few days
The pants are soaking now
I also have some more cotton material to dye now been thinking about poke berries this time
Title:
Post by: Ridge on September 15, 2008, 06:58:48 PM
Quote from: "Mitch"
well, I guess the way I've been dyeing dang near everything(wool, linen, cotton,leather,etc) "theoretically" doesn't work according to some...and I've cold dyed EVERYTHING with walnut hulls or hickory,pecan hulls.....y'all can dye how you choose, but if you haven't tried the way I suggest, don't tell me it won't work....

I assume you are directing this toward me?

I tried your way when I first started learning about natural dyeing.  It makes a tolerable stain.

If you like it like that...God bless you.

I've done it both ways.  You get much more even, vibrant colors my way.  How do I know?  Well, after trying for a year or so your way, I began to use about 25 different plants and about 5 different mordants on different materials using the boil method.  For a couple of years I kept my "swatches" and the data on the combo's.  I found that my methods were repeatable and predictable. The color is more lightfast and withstands washings better.  You can also develop a much wider range of colors to choose from.

I never cared for the "everything from your head to your feet" in walnut.  The old timers loved color just as much as we do today.  As a matter of fact, most of their dyeing was trying to replicate colors that were popular in Europe at the time.

I've learned a thing or two about natural dyeing over the years.  Like I said, it was a hobby of mine.

Feel the love, man.  There's no need to take anything on a message board personally.  It's all about exchanging information and finding a better way to pursue your hobby.
Title:
Post by: Mitch on September 15, 2008, 07:20:00 PM
Ridge-my comments weren't directed at anyone in particular...and I don't wear everything walnut, I have been natural dyeing for a about 7-8 yrs,I've dyed things other folks wouldn't try, I've had good success with my methods(taught to me by some folks who've been dyeing longer than I've been alive, and I'm 47)....you want to be the dye expert and tell folks your way is best, go for it...I've got hunting to do and to much else to pursue to waste time arguing with an expert...
Title:
Post by: Captchee on September 15, 2008, 07:37:39 PM
ok guys
 hat on ,
this isnt how we conduct things here . lets step back , relax and move on .
Jbullard1 has got some honest strait forward replies and  many different  ideas as to what he can do .  Now he can deside for himself  what he like , doesn’t like , what works for him and what doesn’t .
 We don’t need  or want to go down this road
ok , hat off , be nice .
good luck on your hunt Mitch
Title:
Post by: jbullard1 on September 16, 2008, 09:47:04 AM
Well here is what I have now and this is after washing
I'm pleased with the results this time
(http://i170.photobucket.com/albums/u247/jbullard1954/Clothing/Picture002.jpg)
Title:
Post by: Mitch on September 16, 2008, 01:15:11 PM
Looks good!! a few rendezvous, a few hunts and they'll have "patina"!!(fancy French word for "we don't clean our stuff"!!LOL)....
Title:
Post by: jbullard1 on September 16, 2008, 01:28:31 PM
Quote from: "Mitch"
Looks good!! a few rendezvous, a few hunts and they'll have "patina"!!(fancy French word for "we don't clean our stuff"!!LOL)....

Mitch
are you telling me my wife was wrong in making me wash my pants?
They had a whole different look before I washed them  :lol
I think I'll leave the other pair white and just wear them working and let them patina
Title:
Post by: Loyalist Dave on September 16, 2008, 07:25:23 PM
NOW Mitch...,

If I gave you the impression that I was sayin' what you did was wrong, my sincere appologies!  I did write,

Quote
Now the salt will work a bit for some natural dyes ( and it works great on Rit Dye - a chemical dye), and the vinegar is good for wool to keep it color fast, but..., Walnut hulls work best with iron oxide.

Excuse me please for being imprecise, I should've written that salt will work a bit for some natural dyes, and walnut does well with salt, and please note I also mentioned vinegar as you did, but recommended the "best" mordant for walnut is iron oxide, but I should've be clearer and pointed out that iron oxide is the best if one is looking for "colorfastness".  Other methods will dye well, and colors will vary depending on how it's done, but if you are going to wash the item a bit you may want to use the iron oxide.  

I'm sorry.

LD
Title:
Post by: Mitch on September 16, 2008, 07:34:32 PM
no sweat amigos...had "one of those days"....LD-the thing I don't like about using iron(nails,pots,etc)is you get a more black color, not so much to brown...if blackish brown is what you want, adding iron works great...I was also told "most" nut hull dye is a bit self-mordanting(the tannic acid "biting" the dye into the fabric)...anytime I've used iron pots or added nails,etc, I've had a "sadder" color(to borrow a term from Susan Wallace)...it's all good info and it's good to see what others are using/doing....and I use the baking soda rinse to "kill" the acids in the dye and mordant...have a great rest of the week..I'm heading home to hunt this evening(can't get any real time off), need to fill my very EMPTY freezer...Mitch
Title:
Post by: Loyalist Dave on September 18, 2008, 12:48:34 PM
Quote
I use the baking soda rinse to "kill" the acids in the dye and mordant...

Duh-oh!  :bl th up


LD
Title:
Post by: wwpete52 on September 22, 2008, 11:47:13 AM
I soak wood chunks in water when I smoke on the grill.  Sometimes I don't use all of the  chunks and just leave them soaking in the water.  The water turns really dark brown.  I guess that solution could be used to dye cloth. Right?
Title:
Post by: R.M. on September 22, 2008, 11:49:21 AM
I'm going to guess that "Wood Chucks" means something different to you. To me, A "Woodchuck" is a varmint.  :shock:
Title:
Post by: wwpete52 on September 22, 2008, 02:21:07 PM
Not "wood chucks" but "wood chunks."  You know, that stuff you buy at Wal-Mart when you're going to smoke a brisket.
Title:
Post by: R.M. on September 22, 2008, 02:23:07 PM
Ahhhhhh!!!    :oops:
Title: Re: Dye Problem
Post by: bluebottle on April 17, 2014, 01:20:12 AM
In doing some research I found this and it really helped...thx guys.

By the way the woodchucks give a brownish red dye to the cloth I bet lol
Title: Re: Dye Problem
Post by: Swampfoot on October 27, 2015, 08:30:56 PM
Add a rusty piece of metal to the walnut brine might help