So what did Dan'l Boone do? I doubt if he had a JoAnne's down the street, probably no micrometer either. I suspect he would have used whatever worn out piece of clothing that was available and been happy with it.
Yeah, I have several yards of JoAnne's pillow ticking tucked away from which I tear strips for patching, just as I have begun using a ball starter and, for hunting, a bullet board, neither of which have any provenance as being used before the 20th century. But what would have been used "back in the day"?
~Kees~