John, I had an idea it was from those big bores you shoot.
I actually have two names; Ohio Joe and Candle Snuffer...
Ohio Joe came from the first Rendezvous I attended and was introduced as, "Joe from Ohio" therefore they started calling me, "Ohio Joe"
I'm also know as "Candle Snuffer" as I've won more then my share of candle snuffing matches at Rendezvous - so they started calling me; "Candle Snuffer" and sometimes just "Snuffer"
Now a funny story here;
One year at the Ft. Robinson Rendezvous it was on a Saturday Night and visitors (3 ladies from England with their husband's came down to the "Candle Light" Shoot... Red Donker was holding it, and we were shooting at paper targets with just a couple candle lanterns to try and see our target about 15 - 18 yards away. (the targets were hard to see)...
Anyway, a couple of the ladies came to the firing line to watch me shoot, and of course Red was there to score the target once I took my shot... Well they kept asking me how I could see that target and I told them (as Red rolled his head back), "it's not so much seeing your target as knowing where it's at and hitting it" I told them...
So,,, I took my shot and they asked if they could go look to see if I hit it and Red said, "sure" so we all walked down and looked and I did hit it right in the middle... I then had to stand there in the dark while they took pictures of me next to my target and each one of them in the picture as well. They thought it was just amazing and they'd never seen anything like it before...
I remember the ladies telling their husband's about it once we were back at the firing line and one lady telling her husband that I said, "it's not so much seeing your target as knowing where it's at..."
Then Red started laughing silently and shaking his head, as I did as well... Ah, the good ol' days...
Good memories for sure.
So that's pretty much how I ended up with two handles...