Thanks, rollingb. That means I'm golden. My fired patches are light grey and frayed slightly on the edges.
Mark, FWIW, I'm not sure as why it is, but it has been a "Coon's Age" since I found a burned patch.
I used to, years ago, in fact I saw it a lot.
Better barrels, better patch material, better lube?
I have no clue as to when or it how it stopped, it certainly wasn't because I was shooting less powder.
However, I do have a strong suspicion it was better ball and patch fit.
I quit using "one size fits all, pillow ticking" and started adjusting ball / patch to where I needed the short-starter less and less.
I've yet to reach my goal of "thumb starting" on every different gun / caliber I shoot, but I am pretty close on several.
I look at every patch I find. Just a habit I suspect, while realizing I will never find 'em all, so I collect what I can find.
Like you say, there's a bunch of 'em that could easily be used again, perhaps even twice over, but then I think, "where did this round ball impact?"
Was it a 10? Or was it a flyer?
That 'uglier than usual patch' was it a 10 or was it a flyer?
Reading Patches is serious work, work that will make your head hurt trying to separate the wheat from the chafe.
But you have to admit, it's all fun!
Russ...