WELCOME to "The CO."
BTW, if you "pack a "capper", you will be about 20 years into the "future".
As Karen knows, My "persona "revolves" around this time period & area. ( a NWC/HBC mid- upper level) & trying to get a handle on "proper attire"is a "challenge"
Here is my "take"-
1st "rule" = The Men wore "basically" the same attire as they would have worn in their activities "back East". Whether Dress or Work. Their attire would be based on Their "position" in Society/work.
The choice of "foot wear" & Neck wear would depend on your "overall "look" ( Dress,semi dress or work.) ( note - Astor's people (mid clerk level & up) were Scots & some "Yanks"
Neck wear - During this time you would wear either a "stock" or a cravat.
The Cravat
A. All men wore a waistcoat/vest. ( what you "choose" may "dictate" the way you "tie" the cravat.
B. At this time the "fops" made an "Art of doing this, but I would suggest a ""simple style" ( note a cravat is at least 4 1/2'- 5' long & about 3" - 4" wide ) My choice is "the coach or waterfall" ( most often)
Here is a plc to get the "idea"
[albumimg:2j6cy6p4]5223[/albumimg:2j6cy6p4]
Also, I would pick Black for gen. wear, White for Dress. My "look"
[albumimg:2j6cy6p4]4306[/albumimg:2j6cy6p4]
Foot Wear - Here again it depends on Your "looK". ( IMHO, only "fops wore the "pumps etc")The "deciding factor, IMO, is the "style" of garment you are wearing below the waist.
Boots - Very often worn.
A. If your "pant" is more or less "form fitting" then a " over the calf high boot.
B. If your "pant" fits in a way it "drapes over your ankle", then - 1/2 boot or "brogues" ( what I wear )
Buckled Shoes - IMO, only for Dress & with "Knee length breeches" with hose or a Kilt ( yes the kilt was ther & worn by @ least the Scots that came 1st ( via ship.)
Here is my "kilted presentation".
[albumimg:2j6cy6p4]3782[/albumimg:2j6cy6p4]
The long & short of it GO FOR IT , Have FUN & if someone "PCs" you, find Karen, or I am there Me. Trust me they will NOT survive.
Puffer