That's great. I'm not into plastic armor and duct tape. Yes, I'm sure that I'm a horrible stitch-nazi Bastard, but SCA... Hell no! Plastic cosplay... Not into it. "Where is be the dragons?"
As the SMS Rudolf Weiß sails out of a large cordite cloud... mebbee that was too harsh...
Here's the thing... Lots of guys got zapped by someone for being a farb or something when they first tried reenacting. I knew of a silly war unit that thought it was cool to make people cry. The southern guards... I despised them. They hurt the hobby. This kind of crap tends to turn people off and they become like my brother, all butt-holey. With the right intro, new guys learn what is and is not cool. We all rise to our own level of authenticity. Just don't try and spoil another's time trip.
However, there are guys that just refuse to do things like authenticity -- and that's fine. You go to and have your events. I won't be botherin' you
Bad Marsh should also say that he has no problem with CVA's, T/C's, etc. Good guns. Straight shooting too. What fires me up is an automatic knee-jerk reactions to authenticity and peoples belief in. I should, in all fairness state that I do not wear period underwear in ANY time period, including the Roman stuff I do... the boys need support. Anyway, I tell reenactors to beware if some dude demands to see your underwear.