I have bought three guns from them, but only kept one. The one I kept was very nice and I still have it. It's my favorite. The other two when inspected up close did not meet what I wished, so sent it back. That's what the "sale pending" label means on some of the ads..., the buyer is inspecting the gun up close.
I have sold a couple of guns through them too. No worries.
I have noticed, however, that they don't "vet" any of their consignment guns, and I think people are paying premium prices for incorrect pieces because they see them on Track.
I have seen rifles with some seriously basic mistakes (imho) being sold for some rather pricey sums. What I refer to most often is from the photos one can clearly see in some of the rifles, that the lock mortise has too much wood at the mortise tail, at the back of the lock. That's from the builder buying a pre-shaped stock, and not making the lock mortise symmetrical, before going onto fitting the patch box, and then doing the really fun stuff..., the carving. So for me, if the lock area isn't properly shaped..., all the carving in the world can't erase that basic mistake. Putting lipstick on a pig, doesn't change the fact it's still a pig.
The other glaring example is again at the lock mortise. It's very basic that the lock should fit properly, that where the wood meets the lock plate the line isn't buggered, and that there isn't a gap leading into the interior of the mortise with the lock is in place (again imho). Once that happens the builder needs to fix it, or dump the rifle for the cost of the parts and maybe an extra $100 if the rifle shoots right, and start over.
All the carving, tiger striped maple, and metal engraving in the world doesn't atone for a poorly done lock fitting or a poorly done lock mortise. I'd suggest to some builders, that they work on those two items first...., on plain wood...., and only THEN try their hand at carving. Judging from the carving on some I've seen done with poor lock areas..., the building is very highly skilled with wood, but just got in a hurry with the basic stuff.
LD